At the beginning of each semester, Tisch School of the Arts hosts a mixer for students in the undergraduate drama and Film & Television mixer to try and facilitate collaboration between the two departments. Students, however, feel that the school does not do enough in terms of facilitating cross-departmental connections. Calling the mixer “awkward,” “forced” and even “terrible,” they voiced their desire for real opportunities for collaboration.
Tisch junior and film student Alex Sennett felt that these opportunities should be cultivated in class. “If they let you work with the actors in class so you could develop a relationship with them, that would be great,” he said.
Tisch drama senior Emory Kemph similarly advocated for classes that combine majors. Though this type of class has not existed in the past, Tisch is offering a class in the spring 2020 semester called “Directing the Actor,” which will be made up of both drama and film students. While she has connected with some film students outside of class, exchanging contact information so that they could work together again, she definitely feels more could be done by the school to help foster these relationships.
“There’s some encouragement from the professors to work with the film students, but from a practical perspective there’s no facilitation,” Tisch senior Jack Petersen said. He mentioned the Tisch Talent Guild, an online portal “designed to help NYU Tisch Students find and collaborate with artists who can help bring their projects to life.” There are currently four listings on the site, calling for roles like a production assistant or a videographer. One listing is from the father of an NYU graduate, seeking a film student “in need of a class project.”
Clearly, the site is not being used by Tisch students to seek collaborators. The other students interviewed had not heard of it or recognized the name but weren’t sure exactly what it was. “I’ve had way better luck getting work from Columbia MFA film students from their casting portal,” Peterson said.
2019 Tisch graduate Pao Malo noted that film students tend to draw from the same pool of actors for all of their projects. Tisch senior Braxton Fannin agreed.
“Film students were often scared or even resentful of trained actors,” Fannin said.
Sennet admitted that he finds most of his actors on Backstage, a popular platform for casting calls, or through friends of friends, and tends to default to the same handful of actors.
“I have basically a pool of actors who I know I can go back to for anything and they’re all like good friends of mine besides just being actors,” he said.
While Sennet said he is always looking to expand this pool, it can be difficult to make new connections.
“There’s no real way to connect with actors that Tisch provides. You just have to meet them, outside of school,” he said. “They post crew calls all over Tisch film, but they don’t do that for the actors.”
This lack of facilitation reflects a greater deficiency of the school in preparing actors for real, on-set experiences. Peterson said that the preparation Tisch offers for on-set work tends to be more explanatory than experiential.
“It’s definitely difficult to reproduce that experience at a super low budget in class and have it feel the same,” he said.
Other drama students agreed that the department often fails to provide students with these on-set experiences that could better prepare them for film acting, which offers far less rehearsal time and places different demands on the actor than a theater performance.
“Knowing more than one aspect of the industry is crucial to be able to thrive in the professional world nowadays,” Malo said.
While some were optimistic about opportunities for collaboration, others felt that, in such a large department, it is to be expected that students have to seek out those opportunities themselves.
“Sometimes I think it comes down to who you work well with, and that really can’t be facilitated by the department, nor would I want that,” Fannin said. “Just doing my own projects the way I wanted to do them, I eventually found my collaborators.”
Correction, Dec. 13: A previous version of this article stated that there are no course offerings that combine both drama and film students. WSN was later notified that a new course being offered in spring 2020 will have students from both majors. The article has been updated to reflect this information and WSN regrets the error.
A version of this article appears in the Monday, Dec. 2, 2019, print edition. Email Julie Goldberg at [email protected].
Emily K • Oct 21, 2020 at 3:35 am
I came across this article tonight while Googling the Tisch Talent Guild – I was a founding member in 1999 and wanted to see where things had gone since I left in 2003. In the 4 years that I was involved with the TTG, we grew from a small club to a 5-days-a-week office with work study student employees that fielded hundreds of casting and crew calls every week. We connected film kids with actors and vice versa, but we also connected directors with crew, grad students with undergrads, headshot photographers with actors, and theater producers with writers. We also worked with a handful of professional productions to cast Tisch talent. One thing that helped us immensely was our prime location on the ground floor of 721 Broadway – students were popping in our office door constantly to get the word out about their project or just to see what we were all about. When I visited NYU in 2006 or 2007, I was told that the TTG office had been moved to a higher floor of the building, or maybe it was an adjacent building. So much of what TTG did depended on face-to-face connection and getting the word out organically to busy students. Since the problem that TTG aimed to solve (and did solve considerably, for a while) still persists at Tisch in 2019, I would hope that someone at NYU might read this and consider giving TTG or a similar organization a location in a well-trafficked area in 721 that can serve as a hub for students from various departments to connect.