no reactions yet...

The following is a joint editorial that was co-written by WSN and Los Angeles City College's student newspaper, the Collegian, and it is endorsed by student publications across the country. Today, it is being simultaneously published by all cosigning student-run organizations, and WSN is proud to print the editorial in solidarity and in support of collegiate free press.

Los Angeles City College's student-run newspaper, the Collegian, is an award-winning publication that has been in continuous print for 80 years. Its staff of approximately 30 students works tirelessly to publish high-quality content while adhering to rigorous journalistic values. The Collegian is a training ground for writers, reporters, columnists and editors, as are thousands of other student-run publications that hold to the same principles, standards and ethics.

But LACC's president, Jamillah Moore, has made calculated attempts to hinder the students' right to a free press. She has tried to forbid a company working with the college from speaking to the student press; she has tried to pressure student reporters to sign releases for recording public meetings; she has violated California Open Meeting Laws by requesting that reporters identify themselves; and she has attempted to silence the Collegian by slashing its budget by 40 percent — when the budgets of other student organizations were cut only 15 percent. Adam Goldstein, attorney advocate for the Student Press Law Center, said that if he had to choose the biggest First Amendment offender in the country, he would most likely choose Moore. And now, Moore is attempting to move the Collegian under student services, where the administration would have the option to edit all content, monitor stories and determine the direction of the paper.

An attack on free speech anywhere is an attack on free speech everywhere. That is why we, the undersigned, have come together to universally condemn the actions of Moore and the actions of any administration that makes deliberate efforts to break the free speech of student publications.

As students, we have been taught to expect an environment where freedom of speech will go uncontested. And as student journalists, we expect our administrations to understand that we strive to be an objective voice of reason. But we also recognize that any publication that disturbs the comfort of the comfortable will be challenged. Student journalists at the University of Pittsburgh, the University of New Mexico and the University of Oregon, as well as countless untold others, have seen such assaults on their rights. This cannot stand.

We, as student journalists, come together today with a single message: We will not tolerate administrations that, for their own benefit, try to silence the voice of the student free press. We will continue to rebuke those in power who attempt to diminish that freedom, and we will not be silenced.

This editorial was published in and endorsed by the following student-run newspapers:

The Collegian, Los Angeles City College; The Cornell Daily Sun, Cornell University; The Daily Campus, University of Connecticut; The Daily Orange, Syracuse University; The Daily Princetonian, Princeton University; The Daily Sundial, California State University, Northridge; The Daily Titan, California State University, Fullerton; The Eagle, American University; East Los Angeles Campus News, East Los Angeles College; FSView & Florida Flambeau, Florida State University; The GW Hatchet, George Washington University; The Ithacan, Ithaca College; The Maneater, University of Missouri; The New Hampshire, University of New Hampshire; Oregon Daily Emerald, University of Oregon; The Rocky Mountain Collegian, Colorado State University; The Roundup, Pierce College; The Stanford Daily, Stanford University; The University Daily Kansan, University of Kansas; Washington Square News, New York University

3 discussions

Ali

Oct 07, 2009
9:56 a.m.

Muslims throughout the world today --and very successfuly at institutions like the UN-- are whittling away at free speech; OUR free speech. We can no longer call Jihad "Jihad," or Terrorists "Islamic Terrorists," or call the Religion of Peace a religion founded by a warrior who preached and practiced forcibly converting and/or killing all non-Muslims.

Find me an Islamic country --and there are over 40 of them and counting-- where true freedom of speech is allowed. Try calling the royal family o Saudi Arabia a "bunch of hypocrites and lushes" when next in Riyadh and see where that gets you. Or call Ahmadinejad "insane" when next in Tehran to see how freedom of speech is taboo there.. Or call the King of Jordan a filthy Jew when next in Aman to understand what freedom of speech means in Islam.

Is it any wonder this petition and fight is forced upon us by a woman named Jamillah?

Emily

Oct 07, 2009
6:15 p.m.

While I have to respect your right to free speech, I still find your comments offensive. It's not fair to blame an entire culture for a lack of judgment by one school administrator, who may or may not be Muslim.

In Islamic countries, free speech is limited, but that has no baring on our rights in this country. We still enjoy free speech. which is almost unfortunate since it allows comments like this to be said.

Reply to discussion

Ali

Oct 07, 2009
10:57 p.m.

Emily writes, "It's not fair to blame an entire culture for a lack of judgement by one school administrator, who may or may not be Muslim."

I seriously do not follow your logic in the above sentence. Please clarify.

One of the points I attempted to make in my comment is that "Freedom of Speech" is severly restricted throughout the Muslim world. If you believe this to be untrue than let us know how and why you believe differently But by all means do not do so by inclduing a cartoon of Mohammed as part of your answer.

Nor should you criticize Islam for risk of being called an Islamophobe, even if your criticism is spot on.

For instance, if you write that Mohammed was a warrior who killed, raped and pillaged his enemies (non-Muslims) you will be called a hateful liar, even though the Koran is filled with stories describing this very thing; and even though Islamists throughout the world quote chapter and verse from the Koran while beheading people like Daniel Pearl.

Here in the West though, pretty much anything goes. If you want to place your art --and if it happens to be a depiction of someone pissing on Jesus Christ-- chances are the MoMa will display it. And chances also are people will not riot in the streets and kill people and burn down embassies because of your artwork.

In any case, I'm not sure what you are trying to say. I was simply factually laying out some truths about how profoundly different our freedoms are from their lack of freedoms. This is not "offensive" unless you consider telling the truth to be "offensive". If I did so less delicately than is your wont then I'm sorry. I just ask that you do not riot, kill and burn down Dutch embassies in anger over my crass ways.

for free press

Oct 22, 2009
5:37 p.m.

??? where in the article is Islam, or any religion, mentioned ???

Reply to discussion

for free press

Oct 22, 2009
5:34 p.m.

Thank you for an interesting piece.

I am also interested in why the article entitled "Tackling university animal abuse" which was in this same issue, when the link is clicked on, leads to a page saying Oops we can't find that article...

Surely we know NYU uses the same or even more submerged forms of censorship, but this seems an ironic confirmation.

leave a comment

Comments from unregistered users will appear once they are approved. Log in to have your comment show up immediately.


Name
Email
Comment
WSN - New York University's daily student newspaper
7 East 12th Street
Suite 800
New York, NY 10003