Courtesy of Zara Ali

NYU's United Muslims Association held a teach-in at the Kimmel Center yesterday afternoon to rebut "Going Muslim," a controversial column published on Forbes.com last week by Stern professor Tunku Varadarajan.

Images


But rather than condemning Varadarajan's article, most speakers emphasized the importance of solidarity and multicultural understanding in NYU's diverse community.

In his piece, Varadarajan wrote that Maj. Nidal Malik Hasan, a Muslim military psychiatrist who killed 13 people at the army base in Fort Hood, Tex., did not "go postal "; rather, he "went Muslim," a phrase Varadarajan coined to refer to seemingly assimilated Muslim-Americans who choose to vindicate their religion in acts of messianic violence. His column provoked heated reactions from many members of the NYU community.

CAS senior and UMA vice president Wally Omar said he was taken aback and hurt when he read the article, but also recognized the opportunity to respond with open, peaceful dialogue. On Thursday, three days after the column was published, Omar and other students began organizing yesterday's teach-in.

Students wore shirts that said "HARMONYU," and filled most of the space on Kimmel's main staircase at 12:30 p.m. yesterday. The group handed out T-shirts and encouraged passersby to stay to hear speeches and spoken-word poetry.

CAS junior Sondra Morishina, who is on the planning committee for Asian Heritage Month, drew parallels between modern sentiments toward Muslim-Americans and discrimination Asian-Americans have faced.

"All minorities, all immigrants, must stand together when we see injustice against another group," Morishina said.

Bronfman Center Rabbi Yehuda Sarna emphasized the importance of unity and solidarity within diverse communities such as NYU.

"You stand up not just for yourself, but for the rights of other people to have the same benefits as you do," he said.

Before closing the program with a moment of silence for the victims of the Fort Hood shooting, NYU Islamic Center Director and Chaplain Khalid Latif encouraged Muslim students to reflect on their faith and the way their projection of Islam affects others.

For Latif, forging deeper personal connections could be key to avoiding stereotyping.

"It's easier for me to hate you if I don't know your name," Latif said. "Relationships have to move past the superficial."

10 discussions

Sulayman

Nov 18, 2009
2:31 a.m.

Who is that gray-haired individual in the photo? An NYU administrator or dean?

Diane

Nov 18, 2009
1:15 p.m.

David Austell, Director for NYU's Office of International Students and Scholars

Reply to discussion

Ghulam Muhammed

Nov 18, 2009
8:06 a.m.

If only 'going Muslim' had been a spur of the moment conversion, Islam would have come and gone before even a handful of people had time to deliberate.

Faten

Nov 18, 2009
8:10 a.m.

ignorance will always be out there. we need smart young and positive people from all avenues to speak up and educate and unite. great job to all who prepared, joined and participated. god bless

Felsen Stark

Nov 18, 2009
12:32 p.m.

Reading the Islamic texts or learning its history through the eyes of an "unbeliever" reveals the true source of mistrust, deeds will not foster trust until offending texts are confronted and openingly and honestly dicussed.

SteveR

Nov 18, 2009
6:03 p.m.

But what are the *substantive* arguments against Varadarajan's article?

For the kum-ba-yah statements of the people quoted in this article to come from the mouths of intellectuals at a university is truly shameful.

Academics should be dedicated to truth. How about going through Varadarajan's column, sentence by sentence, and discussing whether the words are true are not? Wouldn't that be more productive, not to mention honest, than random spoutings about "injustice" and "standing up for rights?"

Xinjiang

Nov 18, 2009
11:58 p.m.


I am going to write an editorial about how stealing should be now labeled "Going African-American." (I'm not, but you see the point).

I didn't know we needed substantive arguments to answer blind-faced bigotry.

James

Nov 19, 2009
1:32 a.m.

Sure, where can I get my own column in Forbes to rebut everything he said?

Do I really need a whole column to rebut the idea that Muslims like me aren't American? Particularly when a Hindu immigrant like Prof Varadarajan from UK makes this claim? The man is a fool if he claims Muslims aren't civilized, especially when more than Half of Muslims worldwide live in democracies. Does he even know the history of India, his ethnic origin, when the Mughal emperors brought technology and enhanced the culture for centuries?

Reply to discussion

Sondra

Nov 18, 2009
11:50 p.m.

@StevenR

If you had attended, you would know that one professor read from his an analysis of Varadarajan's editorial. In it, he deconstructed Varadarajan's arguments and explained why his claims constituted as hate speech directed towards Muslim Americans.

SK

Nov 21, 2009
5:05 p.m.

"Going Muslim" is exactly right.

Stop mass-murdering other people with your Islamic Jihads, Mohammedan Barbarians.

Robert G Silverman

Nov 21, 2009
5:18 p.m.

The injustice was committed by Major Hassan, not Tunku Varadarajan. I think Varadarajan's article was thoughtful and well reasoned.
.

Larry

Nov 22, 2009
7:12 p.m.

http://www.truthandgrace.com/PresidentialTransitionTaskForce2009.pdf

Does anyone know that Major Nidal was on Obama's transitional task force? Check out page 29.

Shamun Mahmud

Nov 24, 2009
4:39 p.m.

I am going to write an editorial about how saving money is "Going Jewish"
The Semites were
1) The House of Israel
2) The House of Arabs (Muslims)
ALL attacks against Jews AND Muslims are anti-semitic.
Why is this anti-semitic article not being condemned?
This is the best country in the world, yet we tolerate far too much prejudice. This stems from ignorance about our world as well as other societies.
This was dis-heartening, as we have come so far in erasing the mistakes of the last eight years.

leave a comment

Comments from unregistered users will appear once they are approved. Log in to have your comment show up immediately.


Name
Email
Comment
WSN - New York University's daily student newspaper
7 East 12th Street
Suite 800
New York, NY 10003