Sam Cohen

More than one hundred people showed their support at Sunday's vigil for Bauer, Fattal and Shourd.

It's been 100 days of silence. One hundred days of absence. One hundred days since three American tourists have been detained in Iran.

Related

Photos from the vigil held in Washington Square Park on Sunday.

Photos and audio clips from the protest held in Washington Square Park on Sep. 30 for three hikers being detained in Iran.

Park vigil held for hikers detained in Iran

Shane Bauer, 27, Josh Fattal, 27, and Sarah Shourd, 31, were hiking in Iraqi Kurdistan when they accidentally crossed an unmarked border into Iran; there, they were picked up by the Iranian government.

"They just wanted to see the beautiful waterfalls and mountains in Iraqi Kurdistan," Gallatin senior Samantha Feld said. Feld is a friend of Fattal's and organized the vigil in the park to commemorate the 100th day anniversary of her friend's disappearance.

More than 100 people were present at the vigil, which started with a moment of silence for the hikers, followed by a public reading of a letter from the hikers to their families and friends that was sent through the Swiss consulate.

"For the people who gather at the vigils, we can feel it," Bauer wrote in the letter.

According to Samantha Topping, a spokeswoman for the detainees' families, the Swiss consulate visited the detainees twice and reported that they are in good health.

Although this was good news, families and friends are still anxious for their return.

"It's not even about health concerns. It's that they are imprisoned for an indefinite amount of time," said Kristina Lim, 28, who knows Bauer and Shourd.

Lim said that Bauer and Shourd, who are a couple, are very passionate about other cultures and had been spending a lot of time traveling in the Middle East.

According to Fattal's cousin Margerie Applebaum, 56, Fattal is a photojournalist who comes from a family that raised him to travel.

Applebaum said that the families of the detainees are unified in their fight for the hikers' return. They have talked to Congress and met with Secretary of State Hillary Clinton.

"The president of Iran has even promised to encourage the judiciary for maximum leniency," Topping said.

Lisa Ling, former host of "The View," spoke last. Her sister, Laura Ling, and journalist Euna Lee were detained last March when they crossed the North Korean border. They were released this past August.

"I know deeply what the families are going through," Ling said. "Let's keep at it. We're going to get them home soon."

4 discussions

Sulayman

Nov 09, 2009
2:46 a.m.

Here's hoping they get returned soon. Also, the same for the many other people in such situations, stuck in places like Guantanamo for the same reasons.

Ali

Nov 09, 2009
12:57 p.m.

Sulayman,

How can you compare these innocent, care-free hikers with the Guantanamo prisoners unless you are one who excuses Muslims for any and every crime.

The only way you can possibly make this comparison is to assume all the Islamists in Guantanamo had nothing whatsoever to do with Al Qaeda, the Taliban, or any of the other Islamist groups in Afghanistan.

The following short video ends with a picture of how The Islamic Republic of Iran treats outcasts. For you to compare American's behavior with those of Iran tells us more about you than it does about Iran or America's human right's record.

Reply to discussion

Stevie

Nov 09, 2009
3:53 p.m.

there were a significant amount of people who were there on trumped-up or plainly made up charges. unless you think car thieves or random uighurs are terrorists, please stop constructing strawmen.

sulayman was making a comparison between being between two situations: being imprisoned for no discernible reason and not being given access to legal representation. this is true for the hikers, and is true for SOME of the detainees in guatanamo, bagram, etc. nowhere did he say "everyone in guantanamo is totally blameless".

"The only way you can possibly make this comparison is to assume all the Islamists in Guantanamo had nothing whatsoever to do with Al Qaeda, the Taliban, or any of the other Islamist groups in Afghanistan."

this isn't true, but thanks for the representativeness fallacy though!

Ali

Nov 09, 2009
4:58 p.m.

Hopefully here is the video. I've included an extra video which tells me all I need to know about how compassionate and tolerant Islam really is:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_qxjocm5fCc

and,

Muslim at Islamic Community of Greater Killeen, Texas: "I honestly have no pity" for victims of the Fort Hood jihad

James

Nov 12, 2009
3:22 p.m.

They shouldn't have been there in the first place. This is what happens when *privilege* makes people feel they don't have boundaries.

leave a comment

Comments from unregistered users will appear once they are approved. Log in to have your comment show up immediately.


Name
Email
Comment
WSN - New York University's daily student newspaper
7 East 12th Street
Suite 800
New York, NY 10003